SourcingConcentration

Blog

What a concentration ratio tells you that spend data alone doesn't

Vibrant yellow roll-up loading door set into a blue industrial building wall.

A concentration ratio is a simple calculation borrowed from antitrust economics: add up the market share held by the largest few players in a market, and you get a single number that tells you how concentrated that market is. Economists usually use CR4, the combined share of the top four firms. A CR4 of 90 means those four companies control nearly the whole market. A CR4 of 20 means it's fragmented and no single player can move pricing much on their own.

Procurement teams didn't invent the metric, but they borrowed it for a good reason. Swap "market" for "category spend" and the same arithmetic tells you something your supplier scorecard never will: how many of your eggs sit in how few baskets.

How CR4 works on a supplier base

Take your category spend for the year, line up every supplier by dollars billed, and calculate what share of total spend the top four hold. If your packaging category runs $40M a year and your four largest suppliers account for $34M of it, your CR4 is 85%. That's a tight category, concentrated spend, however many logos are on the vendor list below them.

This is where CR4 earns its keep over just eyeballing a spend-by-supplier report. A category can look diversified on paper, fifteen approved vendors, nobody over 20% of spend individually, and still have a CR4 north of 80% once you add the top four together. Spend data alone shows you the ranking. The ratio shows you the shape of the risk.

Most category managers don't stop at CR4. CR1 (top supplier's share alone) flags single-source exposure. CR8 catches categories where concentration is real but spread across a slightly wider group, the kind of thing CR4 can miss if your top four are only moderately dominant and suppliers five through eight still carry real weight. None of these numbers are hard to produce once spend is tagged by supplier. The habit of running them, every renewal cycle, is the part that's rare.

Concentration ratio vs market share: different questions

Market share answers "how big is this one supplier compared to the whole market." Concentration ratio answers "how much of the market, or the category, is locked up by a small handful of players, period." A supplier can have a modest 15% market share and still be part of a category where CR4 sits at 90%, because the other three large players round things out. Market share is about one company. Concentration ratio is about the shape of the whole field.

That distinction matters at renewal time. A sourcing team eyeing a 15%-share vendor might see room to negotiate or dual-source elsewhere. But if CR4 for that category is already high, there may not be anywhere else to go. The concentration ratio is what tells you whether your negotiating room is real or imaginary.

Why track it alongside spend, not as a replacement for it

Spend data tells you what you're paying and to whom. Concentration ratio tells you what happens if one of those relationships breaks, a plant fire, a bankruptcy, a trade dispute, a single customs hold at one port. Risk teams care about the ratio for exactly that reason: it's an early warning that sits upstream of the incident, not a postmortem number you calculate after the line goes down.

The two numbers answer different audiences in the same QBR. Finance wants the spend trend. Risk wants the concentration trend. A category manager who can show both, spend growing 6% year over year while CR4 climbs from 70% to 88%, has a much stronger case for diversification funding than one holding either number alone.

What CR4 won't tell you is where that concentration physically sits. Four separate legal entities can still run out of the same industrial park, draw from the same port, or sit on the same flood plain, and a spend ledger has no field for that. Sourcing Concentration takes the category spend you already track and plots it against supplier geography once a year, so the cluster behind a high concentration ratio shows up as a shape on a map instead of a coincidence nobody caught until the storm season proved it.

If your next QBR already has a CR4 number in it, it's worth asking where those suppliers actually sit on the ground.

← Back to the blog