Field notes: the week two backup suppliers turned out to share a loading dock

A commodity manager I know runs a quarterly dual-sourcing review for fasteners. Two approved vendors per part family, minimum, sign-off from procurement and from plant quality. The kind of control that looks airtight in a RACI chart and gets audited by nobody past year one, because the spreadsheet says the box is checked.
Her team was prepping for a customer audit and someone, out of boredom more than diligence, pulled up the two supplier addresses for a connector family on a map instead of trusting the vendor master. Two different company names, two different supplier codes, two different bank accounts on file. One gate. A single shared loading dock off a frontage road outside Suzhou, with what turned out to be two legal entities operating out of the same compound, sharing the same crane and, as it came out later, the same injection-molding line on a scheduling rotation.
Nobody had lied on a supplier questionnaire. The second vendor was a genuine spin-out, a joint venture structure that made sense on paper when it was set up five years ago. The forms said "independent." The parcel said something else.
This is the part of concentration risk that never shows up in a vendor scorecard: two names on your approved list can collapse into one building the moment a transformer fails, a fire marshal closes a block, or a labor dispute shuts a gate. A dual-source strategy built on two names at the same address is a single point of failure wearing two badges.
Nobody's job is to look at a parcel, and that gap, not carelessness, is what lets this kind of thing go uncaught. Procurement owns the contract, quality owns the PPAP, and sourcing owns the cost model, so the address field sits in nobody's lane until something forces someone to read it as geography instead of data entry.
A junior buyer typed the wrong building number once, three years back, and it's been copied forward in every system migration since. Nobody corrects a field nobody queries.
The industrial-park problem is the more common version of this. You go looking for one shared dock and find six vendors inside the same compound, the same grid connection, the same single road in. Everyone sourced independently, over different years, through different category managers, and nobody drew the boundary of the park because nobody had a reason to. It's what happens when a region becomes efficient at one thing and every buyer in your company discovers that efficiency separately, at different times, without comparing notes.
The fix her team landed on was putting the supplier list on a plan and looking at where the pins landed, since another question on the audit form wouldn't have caught a geography problem. Once you do that, a shared dock becomes the first thing you check before a new supplier gets approved instead of something you stumble on during audit prep three years later.
That's closer to what a yearly pass over the whole supplier footprint should give a category team: a picture of how much of a category sits behind one gate, not just a vendor count. It's a different exercise than reading addresses off a spreadsheet, because a spreadsheet can't show you a shared crane.
The connector family got a third source that quarter, this one genuinely on a different grid and a different road. The audit passed. The lesson stuck longer than the fix did, which is usually how it goes until someone makes the check routine instead of something you only run when a customer is coming through the door.
If your approved vendor list has never been checked against a plan of where those vendors actually sit, run it once through Sourcing Concentration before your next audit does it for you.